Ghost Dances

Ghost Dances: Proving Up on the Great Plains, by Josh Garrett-Davis. Little, Brown, 297 pp. 25.99.

Josh Garrett-Davis has a great personal story.

At two-months old, his parents traveled 300 miles west of their Aberdeen, South Dakota home to the Black Hills International Survival Gathering, the largest protest in South Dakota history. Garrett-Davis describes this as his “first political pilgrimage.”

For the first two years of his life, his parents owned Prairie Dog Records, a fusion of feminist folk anthems, progressive country songs, and drug paraphernalia.

My earliest memory is of a silver paper punch swinging from a piece of jute twine behind the counter of Prairie Dog Records on Main Street in Aberdeen. Records against one wall, the long counter facing them. A dusty glare comes through the front window, and everything is an early-’80s shade of brown, like the stained plywood shelves or the way things must have looked through the big amber-tinted glasses people wore then.

A few years later, when his parents divorced, his mother moved to Portland and discovered that she preferred the company of women. This was all during a time when such behavior was reason enough to be evicted from an apartment, or even to lose custody of child.

Garrett-Davis’s story could have made a great book. That is, had he focused on his own experience. Instead, Ghost Dances is a history of the area where he grew up, bogged down by extensive, exhaustive detail.

Garrett-Davis, who lives currently in Philadelphia, writes Ghost Dances the way an entitled individual would write a book: words expected to be read. Whether the story is engaging does not matter. He has written a book, and that alone is an accomplishment.

I’m not saying that writing a book is not an accomplishment, I know full well how much work goes into a large manuscript. But a book should not be written for the sake of the book. Instead, a book should be written for the sake of the story told.

Ghost Dances has an engaging story, hidden within. What surrounds the interesting points, however, are words that are better off in a classroom textbook.


About katepadilla

I write for the Spencer Daily Reporter in Spencer, Iowa. I keep blogs lifebythebooks, Save Me, San Francisco, and Beauty and Beast Buy a House. I'm also hard at work writing a short story collection inspired by the music of Train.

What did you think?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

Imagine Our Life

Creative living with a toddler!

Bob on Books

Thoughts on books, reading, and life

Tropics of Meta

historiography for the masses

dutch sisters create

As for me and my house, we shall serve the Lord. Joshua 24:15

Kate Brauning

YA author, Editor, Activist, Enthusiast, Fangirl


Covering Atlanta far better than MARTA


thoughts on the stories we love and love to hate

Ben and Becky in Indonesia

Adventures abound!

%d bloggers like this: